Marriage Equality: Work Remains
Despite the U.S. Supreme Court striking down California’s Proposition 8 same-sex marriage ban and a key section of the federal, anti-gay Defense of Marriage Act, much work remains nationally to ensure marriage equality.
There are still 37 states where same-sex couples can’t legally wed. Among other problems, that means many couples may still miss out on family medical leave, Social Security survivor benefits, and other benefits.
But the tide is turning, some advocates said.
"I think there’s a dramatically changed landscape, and as we look at the next wave of states, I also think we’re going to see an increase in support for marriage equality throughout the country," Geoff Kors, senior legislative and policy strategist for the National Center for Lesbian Rights, told the Bay Area Reporter. "Based on the momentum coming out of these two historic decisions, the landscape is going to be changing very rapidly."
NCLR has been involved in the same-sex marriage movement for years, and both Kors, when he was executive director of the LGBT lobbying group Equality California, and NCLR Executive Director Kate Kendell served on the No on Proposition 8 executive committee. That group worked unsuccessfully to defeat the anti-gay measure, which California voters passed in 2008. Last month’s Supreme Court decision upheld a lower court ruling that Prop 8 is unconstitutional. After another federal court lifted a stay on that decision, same-sex marriages resumed last month in the Golden State.
Kors now is helping NCLR on "working with various state groups on a variety of issues," with much of the focus on marriage, domestic partnerships, and non-discrimination. He also serves on the board of directors of Freedom to Marry Action, an affiliate of the national Freedom to Marry organization.
Many see the repeal of the remainder of DOMA as crucial. In a statement Tuesday, July 9 announcing Freedom to Marry’s next phase in its national strategy through 2016, Evan Wolfson, the group’s president, said, "The key to winning is, as it has always been, that when we get to the Supreme Court with the next marriage cases, we go with more states and more support creating the climate for the justices then to do the right thing.
Kors pointed to three states that he thinks will progress on marriage equality "very soon:" Illinois, New Jersey, and Hawaii.
By this fall, the Illinois House is expected to vote on a marriage bill that already passed the Senate. Governor Pat Quinn supports the proposal.
"There’s a real possibility of passing marriage equality in Illinois this year," Kors said.
On its website, Equality Illinois explains a key decision the Supreme Court announced June 26 and how it may still allow states to discriminate against same-sex couples.
"Even though Section 3 of DOMA was found to be unconstitutional, the constitutionality of Section 2, which purports to allow states to decide whether to recognize same-sex marriages from other jurisdictions, remains unclear," the site says. For now, Illinois will continue recognizing out-of-state marriages as civil unions.
"We are working with our national partners and federal administration officials to ensure that all marriages that were validly performed are recognized by the federal government regardless of where the couple now resides. Some federal benefits may be available to you right away," the Equality Illinois site says.
In 2012, advocates filed lawsuits seeking to win marriage equality in Illinois and have asked for an immediate ruling.
Same-sex couples in New Jersey, which also allows only civil unions, face a similar dilemma, since another section of DOMA allows individual states to discriminate against them.
The New Jersey Legislature passed a marriage equality bill in 2012, but Republican Governor Chris Christie vetoed it.
"Obviously the court’s historic ruling on the Defense of Marriage Act was a monumental moment for our movement, but here in New Jersey, it was bittersweet," T.J. Helmstetter, a spokesman for Garden State Equality, said in an interview. In New Jersey, couples in civil unions still won’t be afforded the 1,138 rights and benefits that are expected to go to couples in California and other states where same-sex marriage is now legal.
"It puts New Jersey couples in a precarious situation," Helmstetter said. If a couple married in a neighboring state, "they’re in a situation where every time they cross the Hudson River or the Delaware River to return home from work, they may lose certain rights and benefits every evening."
Helmstetter said marriage advocates are three votes away from the 27 they need in the Senate and 10 votes from the 54 in the Assembly for a veto override.
Advocates have also been pursuing marriage equality in New Jersey through a lawsuit. Since the Supreme Court overturned Section 3 of DOMA, attorneys have requested an immediate ruling in the Garden State suit. A judge will hear oral arguments in August.